Sprinkle & Spark

Ever picked up a snack, supplement, or shampoo, flipped over the label, and seen the words “artificial color” — but no Red 40, Yellow 5, or Blue 1 listed? That little phrase might seem like it includes everything, but let’s clear things up — especially if you’re navigating dye-free living.

What Does “Artificial Color” Actually Mean?

According to the FDA, certified color additives — the synthetic food dyes most dye-free families aim to avoid, such as FD&C Red No. 40, Yellow 5, and Blue 1 — must be listed individually by name on ingredient labels for food, drugs, and cosmetics. You will not see these hidden under vague terms like “artificial color” or “color added.”

So if a product contains Red 40, the label must say “Red 40” or “FD&C Red No. 40.” This applies across categories regulated by the FDA — including foods, over-the-counter drugs, and cosmetics.

Where It Can Get Confusing

Some color additives are exempt from certification, such as caramel color, annatto, beet juice, and other plant- or mineral-based colorants. These are not synthetic FD&C dyes, and they can be listed more generally as “color added” or “artificial color.”

One exception to the rule: carmine (also called cochineal extract), derived from insects, must be listed by name due to potential allergic reactions.

So, in short: synthetic numbered dyes like Red 40 must always be listed by name. But non-certified colorants? Those might still be hiding under a vague label.

Where to Be Extra Cautious

Even though labeling rules are clear, it helps to stay alert — especially with:

• Supplements (especially gummies and chewables)
• Over-the-counter medications
• Cosmetics like lipstick, blush, or foundation
• Toothpaste and mouthwash
• Art supplies and toys (like play-dough), which are not regulated by the FDA

While certified dyes must be listed by name in regulated products, some craft or toy items may not follow the same labeling standards — and that’s where things can get murky.

Tips for Reading Labels Accurately

• Look for specific dye names. Red 40, Yellow 5, Blue 1, etc.
• Be cautious with vague language like “artificial color” on products that are not food or drug regulated.
• Call or email brands if something isn’t clear.
• Apps and databases can help you flag synthetic dyes on the go.

Why This Matters for Dye-Free Living

Learning how to read labels with confidence is one of the best tools in your dye-free journey. Knowing what’s required to be disclosed — and where things might be a little more flexible — helps you make safe, informed choices for your family.

You don’t need to memorize every regulation, but keeping a few of these tips in your back pocket can help you feel more empowered at the store (or when you’re staring down a mystery ingredient).

Final Thoughts

• Certified synthetic dyes must be listed by name on FDA-regulated food, drug, and cosmetic labels.
• “Artificial color” usually refers to exempt-from-certification dyes — but it’s always worth asking if you’re unsure.
• Toy and art products aren’t regulated by the FDA — so do extra digging there.

You’re not being picky. You’re being informed — and that’s something to be proud of.

---

This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical or legal advice. Always check labels directly and consult manufacturers for clarification when needed.